compare and contrast between portia and jessica

She didnt even bother to think about her fathers emotions. Her father set up a will where a person who chose the right casketwould marry her. This also implies that she will not be given the opportunity to exert a significant amount of influence. Bring out the truth of the statement. But Portia is very hesitant to break her oath to her father by helping Bassanio in choosing the right casket. Queries asked on Sunday & after 7 pm from Monday to Saturday will be answered after 12 pm the next working day. She is also a contrasting figure in herself as she believes in the emotional bonds of marriage, but her marriage was an arranged one, she being a reward for Antipholus military service by the duke. Her love for Bassanio is illustrated in her speech where my eye shall be the stream/ and the watery death-bed for him should Bassanio chooses the wrong casket. The lack of power she has in this world because she is a Jewess. Jessica is a plucky woman trying to escape a bad home life. Why does Antonio agree to Shylocks terms for the loan? Despite her submissive and humble attitude towards Bassanio, Portia proves to be a little more superior of the two and is capable of being a strong adversary to her foe. She highly respected her father, though he was dead. The caskets, bearing three separate inscriptions, are meant to separate the gold diggers from the true suitors, a final helpful measure taken by the king to ensure that neither his daughter nor his fortune is taken advantage of. In The Merchant of Venice, Portia has Nerissa. 2023 gradesfixer.com. It is these strict rules, decreed by the two powerful patriarchs, which bring Jessica and Portia together as sympathetic characters in the eyes of the reader; two women deeply in love, unable to consummate their feelings with the men they care for because of the iron rule of their fathers. Let's fix your grades together! Jessica is a Jew and hence Shakespeare portrays her as a controlled character with low self-esteem. Salarino escorts the newlyweds Jessica and Lorenzo to Belmont, and returns with Bassanio and Gratiano for Antonios trial. Before his death, Portias father added a condition to his will, stating that his daughter could only be married to the suitor who selected one of three caskets. When Bassanio, the true love of Portias life, appears, she begs him to take his time so as to insure he will make the correct decision. In contrast, the other two couples - Lorenzo and Jessica, Gratiano and Nerissa exhibit playful or down-to-earth love. Adriana and her sister, Luciana are represented as contrasting figures towards marriage and ones role as a wife. What is the significance of much of the play taking place in Venice? Welcome to Sarthaks eConnect: A unique platform where students can interact with teachers/experts/students to get solutions to their queries. 2018 Apr 17 [cited 2023 May 1]. Similarities between different characters in Merchant of Venice Shakespeare allows Portias character to demonstrate further intelligence by introducing her to state that Clerk draw a deed of gift. The fact that Jessica appears with `page's suit she hath in readiness' emphasizes that she is disguised as a servant. Shakespeare found the story of the lady dressing as a lawyer and defeating the Jew in the Italian tale of "Giannetto and the Lady of Belmonte". He has lost gold, jewels, his daughter, and finally, the ability to continue the family name in the form of a grandchild. on 2-49 accounts, Save 30% One main difference between both woman is that Jessica is Jewish, and Portia is Christian. However, to view him as shallow is probably harsh, unfair and also inappropriate as it was not uncommon for young gentlemen during Elizabethans times to be too free with money with their main occupation being to seek pleasure, fortune and the fairest lady available. Available from: https://gradesfixer.com/free-essay-examples/father-daughter-relationships-in-the-merchant-of-venice/. More books than SparkNotes. It is evident that Jessicas hatred for Shylock is so great, she is willing to do anything, including leaving her homeland and converting religions, just to escape his maniacal control. Wed love to have you back! Here lies the main difference between Portia and Jessica. Get custom essays. Portias wit is again shown in the trial scene, where she cleverly got Shylock to reject in open court both the idea of mercy and the idea of money as alternatives to the pound of flesh. Even though. Their marriage is paralleled by several others: the elopement of Shylock's daughter, Jessica, with the Christian, Lorenzo; and the marriage of Portia's servant, Nerissa, to Bassanio's companion, Gratiano. These contradictions, and his eloquent expressions of hatred, have earned Shylock a place as one of Shakespeares most memorable characters. William Shakespeare and The Merchant of Venice Background. I have some info on Portia and Nerissa, but require info on a foil relationship between: Nerrisa/Jessica,and Portia/Jessica. Portias image is consistent as a goddess, an angel. She marries Gratiano and escorts Portia on Portias trip to Venice by disguising herself as her law clerk. Shylock was a Jew, but Jessica eloped with a Christian in spite of knowing that her father hated Christians. #2 America's Best Cities for Foodies. Latest answer posted December 16, 2020 at 4:51:45 PM. Unlike Portia, Jessica disempowered her father by stealing and distorting his hopes by escaping with a Christian. Shylock was a Jew, but Jessica eloped with a Christianin spite of knowing that her father hatedChristians. Bassanios loyalty and responsibility is once again emphasised in the trial scene, where he refuses to give away his wedding ring. Jessica's discontent with her house and her father was clearly evident when she exclaims that her `house is hell' and looks upon Lorenzo to save her enabling her to become a Christian and thereby enhance herself and her living conditions. This strengthens the concept of Shylock being a heartless villain because his child feels she must leave without a word of her desires. Portia was so devoted to her father that she decided to sacrifice her life by marrying the person who chose the right casket even if she didnt like him. There are some traits of Portias and Jessicas personality that are in sharp contrast with each other . On the other hand, Portias deceased father is only looking out for his daughters best interest, ensuring she find a suitable groom. 2. Dont have an account? She is quite a contrast to Portia who respects her dead fathers will and married according to her wishes. Shylock and Portia's father wishes to control their daughters, though Jessica is a complete foil to Portia in her obedience to her father. Shakespeare makes it clear that Portia is much more than a beautiful woman with access to wealth; she is strong, resourceful, and intelligent. The law! Compare and Contrast a)Antonio and Shylock b) Portia and Jessica Compare and contrast their characteristics. You may cancel your subscription on your Subscription and Billing page or contact Customer Support at custserv@bn.com. All she could say of him was that he was physically tall, handsome and had deep blue eyes with dark brown hair. 1) Jessica was not loyal to her father. Even though her father is dead, she does not break her fathers will. What are the similarities between Portia and Jessica in The - Englicist tirewheelguide.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Later in the play. How are they foils for each-other? By placing Adriana in contrast to her level headed sister, this aids the comical mockery of Adriana and her dramatic expression. Thanks for creating a SparkNotes account! *Room for acting on compassionate feelings. A Modern Perspective: The Merchant of Venice She also stole her fathers ducats and jewellery. *b. To marry Portia, Bassanio must first challenge the casket test and choose one out of three caskets correctly. Portias beauty is matched only by her intelligence. The Merchant of Venice: Themes | SparkNotes KNOW MOREOK. Alejo had been out of the ranches for some time working in the city of Moneterrey when Audelia was still a child, but when he returned to his parents home he saw her and was immediately captivated by her. All the three fathers love their children. * Said she, since i'm to choose and rule as i think fit? However, after closer examination, there are glaring differences between both the situations and the two characters themselves. 2023 Compare Cities Rankings: Portland, OR vs Phoenix, AZ On the other hand, Portia remains loyal to her father even after his death. The Merchant of Venice Study Questions - University of Idaho Answer: Jessica is set on marrying Lorenzo while Portia wants to marry Bassanio. Portias words explicitly highlight her awareness of the way in which the law operates and thereby challenges the perception of women in 17th-century society. Although Portia is richly left, it does not diminish the fact that she is willing to part with much more than what Bassanio had originally borrow from Shylock so as to repay Antonios generosity. This essay has been submitted by a student. Though her father set up a bizarre lottery to ensure his daughter marries, Portia is determined to make her own choices. However, the strict ruling decreed by the patriarchs of the female characters -Miranda, Portia and Jessica - in both . Similar to Lancelots situation, Jessica is ashamed of connected to Shylock by blood. This is further evidence of Shylocks heartlessness. *One thematic issue raised in 'An Angel in Disguise' is that there was little. Where do you want us to send this sample? Contact us One main difference between both woman is that Jessica is Jewish, and Portia is Christian. 2) Jessica is not Afraid or ashamed of breaking her fathers trust on her. The Wifes depiction of her marriages was that three were good and two were bad. The perspective husband and future king of Belmont must choose one of the three caskets. Jessica is the opposite of Portia. Compare and contrast between portia and jessica (project). Like the unsuccessful love stories of the past, Jessica and Lorenzos love is fated to be a failure, while Portia and Bassanios love will flourish. Angered by his mistreatment at the hands of Venices Christians, particularly Antonio, Shylock schemes to eke out his revenge by ruthlessly demanding as payment a pound of Antonios flesh. In turn, this makes the tyranny of the two fathers different as well. Compare and contrast Portia and Jessica in The Merchant of Venice. Shylock tells his daughter, an angel were you, that did preserve me, showing the central role Jessica plays in Shylocks life. On the other hand, Portia was kind and gentle. Ophelia was Queen Gertrude's lady-in-waiting in Hamlet. This rhetorical style is one that you'll see . 3) Jessica shows her embarrassment on her boys disguise while eloping with Lorenzo but Portia talks of her plan to dress like a boy with excitement, i.e., she is not at all shy. As the name suggests, comparing and contrasting is about identifying both similarities and differences. Nonetheless, Antonio is beloved of his friends and proves merciful to Shylock, albeit with conditions. Shakespeare draws our attention to Portias masculine integrity through her ability to govern the drama and dominate the scene. Jessica is a Jew and hence Shakespeare portrays her as a controlled character with low self-esteem. Compare and contrast is a rhetorical style that discusses the similarities and differences of two or more things: ideas, concepts, items, places, etc. You'll also receive an email with the link. For Juliet, it was her Nurse. Their marriage is more of a transaction which follows more closely Lucianas outlook on marriage. Jessica becomes friends with Lancelot, and Portia has Nerissa as her lady-in-waiting. Jessicas discontent with her house and her father was clearly evident when she exclaims that her `house is hell and looks upon Lorenzo to save her enabling her to become a Christian and thereby enhance herself and her living conditions. She knew they were distant relatives, but that was not an issue for it was normal at the time to marry a distant relative due to the seclusion of their. A Jewish moneylender in Venice. Lorenzo, who is a Christian, loves Jessica despite her faith and family origins. A set of three caskets, one gold, one silver and one lead are set before any potential suitor. In fact, he does just that, exiling her inside the house, assuring she will not be sullied by Christian suitors. What are the differences between Portia and Jessica as - eNotes Compare and contrast the 3 women in The Merchant of Venice: Portia, Jessica, and Nerissa. Search Results essays | Marked By Teachers Bound by a clause in her fathers will that forces her to marry whichever suitor chooses correctly among three caskets, Portia is nonetheless able to marry her true love, Bassanio. O my daughter! The third casket is dull lead and says who chooses me will give and gamble all he has. Portias relationship with her recently deceased father was full of respect and, O my daughter! You can specify conditions of storing and accessing cookies in your browser. The Merchant of Venice Father-Daughter Relationships Essay | Bartleby You don't actually make a point with the rings. In the Merchant of Venice, Nerissa, Portia, and Jessica are foils. Her uneasiness also makes a revealing contrast with Portia's attitude to her disguise, and suggests there may be a parallel between the two women. Shylock is trapped when Portia quietly points out that the bond doth give thee here no jot of blood and if he spills one drop of Christian blood in the process of cutting a pond of flesh from Antonio, his lands and goods will be forfeited to the state. He explains to her whatever she wants to do he will submit: And have i won the mastery? Adriana preaches the bonds that married couples inherently share, which she expresses through her dependence on Antipholus, Then is he the ground / Of my defeatures (97-98). After escaping the atrocities of his homeland in Toledo, Spain, Shylock is left with nothing of importance in his life but his daughter Jessica.

Meredith Garofalo Measurements, Half Human Half Deer Demon, Smoky Mountain Plane Crash 1983, Articles C