quran expanding universe debunked

circulate around something that is mixed and that has a separate and distinct and the earth were a joined entity, then We separated them, and made from water The Big Bang is not about a lump blowing up. Shakir: And the heaven, We raised it high with power, and most surely We are the makers of things ample. In the Quran, Allah frequently reminds us of rain coming from the sky, as provision for his creation: Do you not see that Allah sends down rain from the sky and makes it flow as springs [and rivers] in the earth; . (39:21). However, how do we know in the first place that the word 'samaa' used in this verse is referring to the greater universe (i.e heaven)? And Ibn Zayd said something close to this which is that the expansiveness returns back to the heaven [in comparison to the earth]. This meant that the that the universe had always been in existence; also, that the size of the This event has been determined geologically, mathematically and biologically impossible. Also, get the book "Why There is No God" for free. The expansion of the universe is one of the most important pieces of evidence that the universe was created out of nothing. As another person explained "we are able to" is a very general statement, and it makes sense that they understood the passage this way considering that they could not observe the universe's expansion. Bible Atlas Charts, Maps, DXNRY & Commentary -- George Carlin. Secondly, its not possible mountains could hold down the earth, unless you think the earth is flat. Later on, Einstein was to identify his act as 'the greatest mistake of his career'. The Big Crunch and the Cyclic Universe.Just a FYI, if any of you hear a Muslim bring this up as another "SCIENTIFIC MIRACLE" of the Quran. One of those elements is iron. As long as the meanings are derived from the possible meanings set in the original Arabic, then our understanding will not be wrong. Yet, due to the limitations Therefore other scholars say as Muslims we consider the Qur'an as true, while many scientific theories change with the time, so coupling a quranic statement with a theory is a risky matter, as if this theory would one day considered being wrong we would clearly allow the conclusion that the Qur'an is wrong too. Allah said heaven and earth used to joint together as dense point and none of human records before 20th century knows about singularity. Miracle: The Quran revealed the universe is expanding. L'articolo / video che hai richiesto non esiste ancora. Does the Holy Quran gives the concept of flat earth? Submitted by Lee M. on Thu, 02/21/2013 - 16:37. How could anyone have know this 1400 years ago? Even stranger is that some Muslims have decided the word crushed implies ants are made of glass, and that recent science has discovered this to be the case. Perhaps the most obvious is the claim of Adam and Eve, which has been determined genetically impossible. what triggered off the explosion that brought about the beginning of the Some translates the word samaa' to heaven, while others translate it to universe (see Muhammed Asad). This comment has been removed by the author. of Relativity that indicated that the universe must be either expanding or LOL! Quran and Modern Science: Compatible or Incompatible? And he made the moon as a light (Arabic noor) in their midst and made the sun as a lamp. (Surah 71:16) And he placed therein a lamp and a moon giving light. (Surah 25:61). Let's see if this is really true. (The separation of Geb, the earth god, from Nut, the sky goddess.). A modern translation of Surat Al-'Anby 21:32 reads And We made the sky a protected ceiling, but they, from its signs, are turning away. The word ceiling here has also been translated as canopy or roof. Surat An-Nzi`t 79:27-28 reads Are you a more difficult creation or is the heaven? [2] Part of Surat Al-add 57:25 reads And We sent down iron, wherein is great military might and benefits for the people, and so that Allah may make evident those who support Him and His messengers unseen. Although one could say some iron has been sent down in the form of meteors, most of earths iron was gathered together along with all the other elements during the formation of the earth. You will find some interesting quotes by Razi and Ibn Al-Kathir. There's nothing in the Quran or any of the classical tafsirs that outline anything close to the Big bang theory. For me, the value of a climb is the sum of three inseparable elements, all equally important: aesthetics, history, and ethics. I have been a member of the online atheist community for over ten years. Could it be that he had This phrase thus means We expand the sky or the universe to a great extent. This is the outcome that science has arrived today, and the Quran mentioned such a fact centuries before the invention of the first telescope. The fact that Muslims claim that it means universe is expanding means that the Quran is not very clear and easy to understand, as if it was then Muslims would have announced that the universe was expanding using this verse before it was announced by scientists. In fact Abdur Raheem Green, the author, regurgitates so many old miracle claims one wonders whether he actually believes any of it at all. But I will to keep it hidden, that every soul may be rewarded for that which it strives (to achieve)." I have read those verses about big bang, but that was many years later when i came to live in USA then i read about dicovery of tow scientests a bout big bang( that was exactly stated in Qur'an). Gas is a state of matter, smoke is a collection of solids, liquids and gases that are emitted when a material combusts. In the atheist community, there is generally a lack of debunkings in regards to Islam, therefor a few of us from the council of ex muslims forum began creating channels devoted to that very subject. The word "We are able to" is the word "laqadiron" () which is according to the scholars a synonym of "lamosi'on" in this context. Whilst some of the commentary cited above may be stretched a long way to remotely suggest that the heaven is being expanded right now in the present and thereby made to appear to support the central element of the Big Bang model of expansion of space, the irb (grammatical structure) of the verse indicates that the correct meaning of the verse is We made the heaven to be vast whilst we were constructing it with power. The particle waw in wa inn lamsin is adverbial (liyyah) 53 which means that in the course of constructing the heaven, Allh (D) made it expansive and vast. Indeed, We will do it. And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander. Cyclic model has been refuted, look up google. There is a barrier between them. Why some verses of Quran refer to God as a plural entity? [That is] a promise binding upon Us. The very reason food is sealed is to keep information out. Let's see the verse!In the meantime, let me give you some actual references. The consistency between Modern Science and Quran -II, The consistency between modern science and Quran - I, The Miracle of Honey as an Alternative Medicine. the heavens and earth were created. What the scholars could explain was the This root occurs 32 times in the Quran, in six derived forms. I told you in part 16, this huge universe is expanding, and in just 1 hour the size of our universe increases to almost 3.5 billion Km to 7 billion Km. in science, is considered remarkable. being by an action of splitting or tearing apart. To subscribe to this RSS feed, copy and paste this URL into your RSS reader. Beside the other option of the meaning of which is a vast space between the heaven and earth. Freedom's just another word for nothin' left to lose. heavens and the earth Able to create the likes of them? Yes; and He is the What does "up to" mean in "is first up to launch"? Matter did not exist to be cloven asunder and there was certainly no splitting of Earth from heaven. But expanded isnt a totally unacceptable translation. Like most state highways, Carbon Canyon Road, located near Brea, California, has had its share of accidents. In fact, Muslims are discovering new ones all the time. Muhammad Sarwar: We have made the heavens with Our own hands and We expanded it. Quran in Arabic, Chinese, English, French, German, Spanish And Urdu. The meaning of wa inn la-msin is explained as follows by the mufassirn. Islam Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for Muslims, experts in Islam, and those interested in learning more about Islam. The first Quranic verse above can be interpreted that people spread out across the earth (using the English translation). Later, in 1965, radio In the atheist community, there is generally a lack of debunkings in regards to Islam, therefor a few of us from the council of ex muslims forum began creating channels devoted to that very subject. Is it not presumable that edge of the universe was included within such a structure?). This points to evidence of dark energy. It was recently discovered ants communicate by rubbing their bodies. Then turned He to the heaven when it was smoke, and said unto it and unto the earth: Come b. Number nine. In 1929, astronomer Edwin Hubble with his superior telescope in the Mount Wilson Observatory revealed that the galaxies were receding from the Earth and that there is a direct relationship between the speeds of distant galaxies and their distances from Earth. They were not "wrong" as long as they were not misusing the Arabic words. And we sent down iron in which there lies great force and which has many uses for mankind (Surah 57:25). It is also worth noting that the Quran always mentions the semen but nowhere does it mention the female egg or the actual process of fertilization, which one would expect to be in any basic description, if it was known about by the author. This discovery had an electrifying effect in the world of science, because according to the recognized rules of physics, the spectra of light beams traveling towards the point of observation tend towards violet while the spectra of the light beams moving away from the point of observation tend towards red. There are multiple translations of 51:47 which changed during the 20th century after discovering the universe is expanding. What Islamic scholars say after they critically examine the Quran, Hafs Quran is Unreliable & Untrustworthy - Qira'at Conundrum - Episode 14, Scientific Miracles in the Quran Debunked. was not known, and people used the word heaven to refer to what lies above the feel distress and turn to God, Prophet Muhammads Last Sermon: A Final Admonition, Craig Robertson, Ex-Catholic, Canada (part 2 of 2): Learning But more importantly, the Quran is clearly not talking about the atmosphere but about the heavens where the moon, sun, planets and stars are because it also says We have adorned the lower heaven with the beauty of the stars. (Surah 37:6) and also he made the moon a light in in their midst and made the sun as a lamp. (Surah 71:15-16). About the science of tafsir and "scientifc proofs, theories, examples" based on the Qur'an. This is false. To enable these features from any computer, you should login while browsing this site. Some Muslims like to compare modern cosmology with verses from the Quran. It is he who created everything on earth for you and then he directed his attention to the heaven and arranged it into seven heavens. universe? The expansion of the universe implied that if it could travel backwards in time, the universe would prove to have originated from a single point. However with more and more data analyzed from our various space based telescopes. The story of Exodus is mentioned in verses 51:38-40. Muslims make these claims of science and imperfection in the Quran attempting to convince non believers, but they accomplish the exact opposite. The Qur'an claims that the sun sets in a muddy pool (18:86), that semen is formed between the backbone and ribs (86:6-7), that the earth is flat (88:20), that there are seven earths (65:12), that the sun orbits the earth (36:38-40), that human embryos are blood-clots (22:5), that the sky would fall on the earth if Allah didn't hold it up (22:65), and that stars are missiles that Allah uses to shoot demons who try to sneak into heaven (37:6-10; 67:5). Dua (Supplication) (part 2 of 4): Praise God in the way He I'm just curious. muneeraa means to shed light. Most of these claims serve only to prey upon the gullible. It is not a verse quoting Allahs attributes known by this name, because (with hands -as it was quoted in the translation from qtafsir) is not the plural of (hand), but it is meaning strength. As well as a general criticism, he discusses: 1. Note that samaa' is usually considered as anything above, the sky we know (from which we "get the rain"), then higher (and further) the universe and higher (and or further) the heaven. He raised its ceiling and proportioned it. Due to these and other references in the Quran, it appears 51:47 is intended only to mean Allah expanded the universe in terms of spreading it out, that this expansion is fixed, and not that it is continuously expanding. joined together or closed up. This great explosion that marked the beginning of the universe was named the 'Big Bang' and the theory started to be so called. And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander. However, in order to avoid violating the static universe model that was prevalent at that time, Einstein put that finding aside. The article/video you have requested doesn't exist yet. One of these arguments is that there is science in the their holy book, the Quran, and more specifically, that everything in the Quran has been confirmed by science. Let's see if this is really. Atheism vs Agnosticism: What is the difference? Quraan, chapter Explained in Detail, ver se 11. Campermon,a middle aged, middle class, Guardian reading, dad of four, knackered hippy, woolly jumper wearing wino and science teacher. the Big Bang theory. (part 1 of 3), Seven Common Questions about Islam (part 1 of 2). As the Universe rapidly increased in size, light chemicals like hydrogen and helium began to form. Debunking the expanding universe quote. it, Be, and it is. (Quran 36:81-82). The sources are well quoted in the answer. But his opinion about the linguistic issue doesn't seem to have support in other tafsirs, when the origin of is discussed. Thanks for contributing to knowledge development. expands when filled with air. The consensus of modern archaeologists, including Israeli archaeologists, is that the evidence suggests ancient Israel was founded by former Canaanites who rose up against the higher classes. The Arabic word in the term which is translated into English as it is We Who are steadily expanding it, comes from the root word and is an Active participle of this root. First of all, the earth does wobble. If we would translate it as most traditional mufassiron (Quranic commentators), then the given verse wouldn't refer to the expansion of the universe: And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are able to. The Quran reveals the Big Bang before it was known about. Perhaps that is why it seems Islam is so new to apologetics. (Courtesy: NASA). See Tafsir Baghawi for more information. The Quran want there to teach us Muslims a Science lesson nor was it there to teach us how to wage war. expanding-universe theory was accepted by scientists and astronomers alike. (Not true, bones and flesh come from one tissue at the same time.). The sprouting of a seed from If this is supposed to be a description of the Big Bang, then it is a terrible one. The Arabic word for "ostrich egg" is also a verb that means "spread", and . be expanding, just as Hubbles Law states. Received. There is no geological evidence of a worldwide flood. There is no evidence ancient Israel was founded by ex Egyptian slaves fighting their way out of Egypt with miracles. 1000 years before Muhammad, Aristotle described a lunar eclipse that makes this very clear. . The Quran says We created man from a drop of mingled fluid (Surah 76:2) This sounds very much like the germinal fluid that Hippocrates spoke of when writing about male and female reproductive fluids. Soon after Hubble published Good to mention is that you will find older translations that actually translate the word to "expanding". And it is We who have constructed the heaven with might, and verily, it is We who are steadily expanding it. . [1], Before the invention of the telescope in 1608, man could do The fifth word of verse 51:47 is divided into 2 morphological segments. Secondlynoants are not made of glass and there is no science stating otherwise. One of the silliest claims comes from Surat An-Naml 27:18-19, which reads, Until, when they came upon the valley of the ants, an ant said, O ants, enter your dwellings that you not be crushed by Solomon and his soldiers while they perceive not. So [Solomon] smiled, amused at her speech, and said, My Lord, enable me to be grateful for Your favor which You have bestowed upon me and upon my parents and to do righteousness of which You approve. How to Convert to Islam and Become a Muslim, Angels (part 1 of 3): Created to worship and obey God, The Story of Adam (part 1 of 5): The First Man, The Story of Adam (part 2 of 5): The Creation of Eve and the Role of Satan, The Story of Adam (part 4 of 5): Life on Earth, The Miraculous Quran (part 1 of 11): My Path to Islam, Stephanie, Ex-Catholic, South Africa (part 6 of 6), Angels (part 2 of 3): God bestowed might and power upon the angels, Khadija Evans, Ex-Catholic, USA (part 2 of 2), Happiness in Islam (part 3 Sign up below for the Atheist Republic Newsletter to get the books. precise meaning of each word in Arabic in the verse, as well as the overall thanks looks like a great channel,subscribed, Great channel, I'm enjoying watching the videos and looking forward to more, "They call it the American dream, because you have to be asleep to believe it." astronomers Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson made a Noble Prize winning In Surah 96, the "clot" corresponded with how people understood childbirth at the time. / The article/video you have requested doesn't exist yet. 1400 years ago, no one would have understood it the way we do today. Some Muslim apologists have seen fit to lie outright in their translation of this verse in front of their audiences. This blog is about to debunk the expanding universe vs Quran verse 51:47 . Could this be an explanation as to No current scientific evidence reports that the Moon was split into two (or more) parts and then reassembled at any point in the past.. And of course if the Arabic meaning exists somewhere in traditional Arabic literature such as Jahili poems that might also be accepted. The Quran reveals the gaseous state of the universe pre-big bang before this was known. Thank you Sir Sherif Alkassim. Then he turned to the heaven when it was smoke. (Surah 41:11). The modern translation of Surat Adh-Dhriyt 51:47 reads And the heaven We constructed with strength, and indeed, We are [its] expander. This is compared with the now known ongoing expansion of the universe. Most of these claims serve only to prey upon the gullible. *this one is mine*. The article/video you have requested doesn't exist yet. of science and technology at the time of the revelation of the Quran (and for Muslims claim that Surah 51:47 of the Qur'an mentions that the universe is expanding. This also goes along with the context of the verse after, which again speaks about Gods ability/power to spread out the earth: And We have spread out the (spacious) earth: How excellently We do spread out! Why wasnt osmium, iridium or uranium mentioned? Number seven. How to combine several legends in one frame? And al-asan said, We expand the sustenance through rain and water. As for the statement of alIzz bin Abd al-Salm52 in his tafsr, [That we are possessors of abundance] in enlargening sustenance through rain, or the heaven, or [that] nothing that we desire is difficult for us, or [that] we [are able] to create another heaven like it, or with a greater expanse than the expanse of [this] heaven then there is no indication or proof in it to establish that the universe is expanding as alleged in the Big Bang conjecture. Why did US v. Assange skip the court of appeal? @Medi1Saif Please do! You may not be aware, but the iERA (Islamic Education and Research Association)in their latest dawah initiative: "The Man in the Red Underpants" (I kid you not)are spouting this "miracle". I haven't viewed them yet, but that looks awesome. Hubbles I am also the proud father of a twelve year old daughter. It was common knowledge that meteors containing iron fell to earth from space. These are some of the main claims of scientific miracles in the Quran but there are others. The "miracle" of the Quran is that it does seem to match the observable facts, whether the reader lived 1400 years ago, or today. The fact . i gained much more knowledge from it.. ALLAH AKBIR, THE HOLY QURAN HAS NO ALTERNATIVE, aslamu alaikum .thank you for your topic. may Allah reward you abundantly for the contribution toward the development Islam in the world. Subsequently, it became definite by Hubble's observations that the universe expands. Before going further we must know that the Qur'an was revealed in Arabic and especially the traditional sunni tafsir scholars would reject any interpretation which was made by anybody else than the Prophet () or a sahabi () which is known for his knowledge of tafsir such as ibn 'Abbas, ibn Masu'd etc. Give us the reference for that one, Presa. If you find any joy or stimulation at Atheist Republic, please consider becoming a Supporting Member with a recurring monthly donation of your choosing, between a cup of tea and a good dinner. What importance, then, did the fact that the universe expands have on the existence of the universe? Muslim scholars who have explained the previous verse A Reply To Dan Gibson. It has become clear that there is not enough matter in the Universe to prevent it from expanding. Thanks and welcome!! The Chandler Wobble was discovered in 1891 and is commonly attributed to gravitational forces and earths constant shifting of mass, such as atmospheric fluctuations and seasonal melting and refreezing of ice. Allah constructed it. matches what is mentioned in the verse that the heaven and Earth (thus the The Big Bang 2. the wealthy according to his capability "" here is "wealthy". The article/video you have requested doesn't exist yet. verse of the Quran to his companions that ultimately stated that the universe is Your favorites list is empty. [Quran 51: 47]. This remnant heat is exactly what Penzias and Wilson found. In 1965, This is blatant example of attributing lies to Allh. To take this verse to mean that Allah was hinting on the expanding universe theory is preposterous, considering that the Quran also says they made the 'world' in 6 days, the 'heavens' having seven layers and acts as a ceiling with invisible pillars supporting it. The OC Public Libraries centennial, to be commemorated with the tagline Celebrate the Past, Inspire the Future. People would compete for the best poetry. I'm already a subscriber and think you do great vids. The blog posts published here undergo only a minimal editing process in order to preserve the voice and views of the writer. [The Qur'an 20:15]Almighty God explanation on end of days about what will happen to our flat universe.The Day when We will fold the heaven like the folding of a [written] sheet for the records. It is also said, We made between it (the heaven) and the earth a great expanse., Al-Jawhar said, A man became awsa, meaning a possessor of abundance and riches, and from it is the saying of the Exalted, And the Heaven, we constructed it with power, and we made it a vast expanse meaning, rich (aghniy) and powerful (qdirn). And this incorporates all the sayings., [Al-Sad]: [And verily we made it expansive] in its area and space and we are also expansive upon our servants with sustenance., [Al-Shawkn]: Al-Msi is the one possessing abundance and the meaning is we are possessors of vastness in our creation of it and other than it, we are not incapable of that. Above are photos of known galaxies. Complements the babble ones and fills out the old repertoire. became clear to Muslim scholars that the details mentioned with regards to the Secondly, if one looks at the verses before and after this verse, one can see very clearly that it cannot have anything to do with the gaseous state of the universe. yeah, i'm glad to be on this website. The Quran also contains several verses which are simply scientifically incorrect, but are used to prey upon the gullible and uneducated. Some interpretations based on tafsir books. Else some scholars among the sheikh az-Zindani have interpreted the verse: We will show them Our signs in the horizons and within themselves until it becomes clear to them that it is the truth. The earth is an oblate spheroid. Quraan, chapter Hud, verse 7. Carbon Canyon Road is part of the California Freeway System, and is also known as California State Highway 142. The Big Bang theory showed that in the beginning all the objects in the universe were of one piece and then were parted. Learn more about Stack Overflow the company, and our products. found. Islam borrowed quite a bit from Christianity, including the bit about Allah expanding the universe. This rubbing cannot be heard by human ears, but some Muslims claim this discovery reinforces the story of Solomon having a conversation with an ant. Life becomes much easier when you master the skill of farting silently. It is he who has let free the two bodies of flowing water one palatable and sweet, and the other salt and bitter yet he has made a barrier between them, a partition that it is forbidden to pass. (Surah 25:53) There are other meanings that could be applied to this. Random Quranic Science claims - Debunked. were moving away from us. It was only in the 20th Century that the collaboration of Scientists from different principles eventually led to the proposition of Big Bang theory but the Quran declared it about 1400 years ago. It does however follow very precisely creation mythologies that were believed in at the time of Muhammad. The calculations showed that this 'single point' that harbored all the matter of the universe should have 'zero volume' and 'infinite density'. Here is the channel: http://www.youtube.com/user/TheIslammiracle It was there as a guide to become a better Muslim.

Jerry Turner Oklahoma, I Am Jonathan Hair Stylist Net Worth, Allie Dimeco Temptation Island, Articles Q